Wasn't Goa considered sovereign Portuguese
territory?
Balaji Viswanathan, History buff.
1. Distracted US
administration: Nehru timed the
aggression within months of JFK taking over. The new administration was still
learning the ropes and was too busy focused on the botched "Bay of
Pigs" operation in Cuba. When India took the administraton by surprise,
all the President could say was a dignified "Oops!"
2. Colony or
Province? As mentioned by User there was an
argument on whether Goa was a province of Portugal or a mere colony. Given that
US and Canada were colonies once, they were somewhat sympathetic to India's
cause in fighting a colonial power despite Portugal's argument that Goa is a
province (who were they kidding?). US didn't want NATO to be seen as siding
imperial powers & lose political capital & credibility at a very
critical time in Cuba & Vietnam.
3. World opinion. Most of the world - from newly liberated colonies in Africa,
West Asia, East Asia to USSR & Soviet bloc countries to even China -
supported India. NATO's targets are usually isolated countries that no longer
have friends (say Milosevic's Serbia or Saddam's Iraq). India had established
itself as a leader of the third world and it was politically very expensive to
act against India. This was especially important as IndoChina (Vietnam) was
starting to boil and any action against India was bound to screw up everything.
For most, Goa was too unimportant compared to the action in other places.
4. British
neutrality. Although
Britain was a close friend of Portugal, they also sympathized with the Indian
cause and decided to stay neutral. Canada, Australia and other Commonwealth
members of NATO were also eager to maintain their relationship with India and
were against a NATO action.
5. JFK bias. Although the Eisenhower administration (that ruled US until
1960) was more friendly to Portugal, the Kennedy administration that took over
in 1961 was more liberal and more sympathetic to India. Nehru timed his
takeover of Goa well (waiting for Eisenhower to leave office). It is
questionable whether India would have taken over Goa in 1961 if Nixon had won
against Kennedy.
Kennedy and
Nehru meeting weeks before the Goa liberation
6. UN Veto: Portugal and US tried to use the UN for an action. Thanks to
USSR Veto, UN Security Council refused to vote against India. This made things
even more complicated.
7. Personality of
Salazar. Salazar
(dictator of Portugal) was not a likable figure and as an autocratic dictator
he didn't have many friends in the liberal minded members of NATO.
8. Weakened
administration. Although Adlai Stevenson II (US ambassador
to the UN) spoke eloquently against India, he had little credibility even in
the US. Even his own government did not debrief him regarding the Bay of Pigs
crisis and made him appear stupid when talking about the subject in the General
Assembly. In short, India's enemies were quite weak at that time and had no
political capital to make a significant impact.
No comments:
Post a Comment