Why are all political parties so desperate to remove the BJP/Modi from the central government?

Answered thru Quora Digest by

Mrutyunjay Joshi

Mech. Engineer, Economist, worked with MNRE Govt. of INDIA.

Because they left with no other business now.

Though first coalition Govt. in india was formed under the Prime Ministership of Morarji Desai but it didn’t last long and the govt. with complete majority returned.

Indian politics completely changed after the death of Rajiv gandhi and the era of the coalition came (1989–2014)

Just after the 1989 you can see the victory margin is quite reducing in trend. 5 prime ministers changed in 10 years and total 8 prime minister till 2014 from Vishwanath Pratap Singh to Manmohan Singh.

So whether one is in opposition or in majority he/she always had a role to play in the governance of India. No political party in rule can ignore those in opposition before taking any major decision. Thus terms such as policy paralysis was wide used in media.

Non-majority was never ignored till 2014 in policy framework at national level. Indian politics had by now become a game of only politics and less governance. Example the coalition partner all always demanded Railway ministry (Lalu Prasad Yadav Mamta Banerjee, etc) as there was separate budget which they can prepare.

Money changed hands to make opposition agree on matters, frequent fear of no confidence motion, almost populist policy were only adopted. A Single ideology of rule or governance was completely gone in this years.

Thus there was gain of small or large to all the political party whether they are in power or not. Politics had eclipsed the governance.

Just as eclipse is not permanent, 2014 came. The days on coalition politics got over. NDA coalition of 2014 was merely a formality and good will gesture.Separate Railway budget was also stopped. Thus it was clear BJP ideology with complete majority, no more fear of no confidence, and it helped BJP to focus more on governance.

So all the political and financial gains which they used to get, to be on board with the govt, were stopped. One can roughly say opposition had completely lost its business governance. So today they will protest even on Swachh Bharat Mission too.

This the reason why all opposition are now united like a Labour union and willing to take India again in that era of “all party gain coalitions.” So think twice before voting for the coalition called, Mahagathbandhan.

Note: A stronger opposition is very much needed in democracy but not in governance. One can have many good boats to choose from, but one cannot ride them all at same time.

Another Answered By

 

Vishnudas Pai, Consultant in Heavy Engg Industry (1984-present)

Answered Sep 3

Dear Kabir Dashji , your question itself answers to good extent. Opposition parties are desperate to remove plus not to allow him to return as PM .

When can such a thing can happen: there are two possiblities.

Either he is too bad .

or he is too good and opposition parties are jealous of his returning will destroy thier hereditary business of politics made into a cozy dynastic profession from Kashmir to Karnataka.

Now let us consider few parameters :and then we will conclude who is bluffing./ Who is telling the truth bcoz facts and figures speak for themselves.

1. FDI:

The Modi effect: US FDI into India has jumped 500% in the last two yearsthe FDI in 2014 was $36 billion and it. is $ 209 billion in 2017 .if Modi govt was bad how such a six times jump in Foreign Direct investments can take place ??.?are all foreigners are just fools to invest in India if Modi govt is so bad ????

2) Insolvency and Bankruptcy code :

Over 2,100 companies settle Rs 83,000 crore bank dues - Times of India

Above proves effectiveness of IBC over 2100 indutrialists returned over Rs 83,000 crores of bank loans hurriedly due to the scare thier companies will be sold off by govt.

Above link also says more than 4,00,000 crores of banks money out if NPAs have come back to banks ,and lot more expected very soon.

Why this code was not brought in last 71 years by previous governments ???

3) Gas connections to poor :

Modi says 10 crore LPG connections given in 4 years

Above report says since independence 13 crores connections were given total ( Not free) in Modi govts 4 years iver 10 crores free gas connections given to poor people .With this poor people can live comfortably and spend thier time to earn something extra and help educate thier children and also reduce atmospheric pollution.

4) Mudra :https://m.economictimes.com/indu... it days over RS 6,00,000 crores loan given to poor without collaterals benefeitjnvbover 12 crores people bulk of which are SC and ST people .

Why this was not done by earlier govts ?!

5) Modi govt built 6 crore toilets since coming to power in 2014: Union minister - Firstpost above report says over 6 crores toilets built by govt in 4 years which will be 8 crores by next 2019.Since independence how many toilets were built by govts ???

6) Electricity.Narendra Modi claims all Indian villages have electricity access: 10 facts that put accomplishment in perspective - Firstpost

Above report says last remaining 18,452 villages we're all electrified by now.Dors it require 70 years to electrify all the villages ??

7) GDP: Indian economy has jumped five ranks in 4 years of Modi government: Nilesh Shah, Kotak AMC the above report shows India which was 10 th in global rankings now jumped to 5 th ranking in Modi govts’ 4 years..is it just a fluke ???

8) Solar energy generationEight-fold jump in solar energy capacity to 22 GW in four years: Government the above report says there is 8 fold jump in solar energy generation in Modi govts 4 years from 2.63 GW to 22 GW.How did it happen ???

9) successful implementation of GST : GST: GST Revenue collection for April 2018 exceeds Rs 1 lakh crore the above report successful implementation of GST and robust collections on upswing.All paperless , digital , transactions taking place reducing corruption to minimal levels , and increasing tax collections meanwhile.why was it not done by earlier govts ???

,10) Highway construction: NDA government built 73 pct more highways than UPA’s last 4 years the report says NDA built over 73% more highways than UPA.This increased employments and also FDI.

11) Health care : national health insurance scheme : Budget 2018: Arun Jaitley announces Rs 5 lakh insurance for poor families in ‘world’s largest’ healthcare scheme above scheme provides health coverage for over 50 crores benefeciers and is getting launched on 25–9–2018.

13) Pension scheme for unorganized sector: For bulk of the India's unorganized labour force social security is created by this scheme.

Atal Pension Yojana - Government Guaranteed Pension Scheme for the Unorganised Sector why was it not done by earlier govts ???

12) Increase in income tax collections and increase in tax payers numbers post demonetization: Everyone crying hoarse that it is a big failure..If it was so govt getting additional Rs200,000 crores or more every year ,you call it a failure ???

With 99.49 lakh new tax filers, income tax returns surge 26% in 2017-18

Demonetisation effect: Income tax returns rise by 25%, collections up by 41%nearly one crore increase in tax payers and over Rs200,000 crores of increased income tax collections .

The above are only few examples (can never be a fluke )as to what Modi govt has done which definitely ranks India much much higher in the the world.Now is it clear to all Modi govt is a performing govt ( in employmend,in FDI,in GDP,in tax collections, in infrastructure building ,in toilets building , in free gas connections ,in providing health care for poor people,in solar energy generation , in electrification of all the villages , in recovery of Nonperforming assets of banks practically in everything ) Now it is Crystal clear what all blatant lies opposition parties are using to say govt has failed ???? Really ???? Is there any other developmental agenda for opposition parties ??? No never..So all indians can be sure NDA govt has performed in exemplary manner in everything. All the opposition claims stand dismissed in toto as unfounded, malicious,baseless and treasonous at it's worst.